McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) Conservation Accidents

McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) Conservation Accidents Naughty Teddy Experiment This experiment aimed to stimulate Pia brooks line of work of list conservation. The slightly adapted landing field by McGarrigle and Donaldson had a condition in which the counters appeargond to move accidentally and with a depressed teddy rather than Pia acquires method acting of deliberately moving the counters himself. 80 participants were involved in the study who were 4 to 6 years, they were subjected to the experiment of counters where the experimenter presents children with both rows of counters and asks them if there are the similar yield in each row, past a gloomy teddy runs across the table and accidentally knocks the counters in unmatched row closer. The same question of comparing the counters is then asked again. The findings demo a large difference between the two conditions in Piagets study and McGarrigles study. 16% of children correctly dissolving agented the q uestions in Piagets study compared to 62% of children resolventing accurately in Mcgarrigles experiment with the naughty teddy. Mcgarrigle et al concluded that children acquire their intelligence of number conservation at an earlier age than believed by Piaget. And that results lay down by Piaget were in response to the difficult questioning.

Evaluation A main criticism of the standard Piagetian conservation lying-in is that asking two separate questions may confuse the child. nevertheless in the Naughty Teddy experiment there is an attempt to subdue the problem of the child believing he is to change his e xercise to the second question. It is Naught! y Teddy that mischievously rearranges a row of counters and in so doing, confuses the experimenter. This allows the experimenter to use the second question without inferring that a change of settle is required. Mcgarrigle and Donaldson made the experiment more child friendly by introducing an object the children could relate to and so they could understand the questions asked of them without...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper